[pobo]

1. Julius Ceasar
2. Desert Fox ( this guys doesn't get enough credit)
3. Robert E Lee...He could of created more strategic positioning for the Confederates.
4. Khalid ban Walid
5. Alexsander
6. Napoleon
7. Hannibal
8. Mcarthur
9. Gengis Khan

IMO...What do you guys think?

[MMA Fighta]

Jesus

[pobo]

Originally Posted by MMA Fighta

Jesus

k...? Can you be a little bit more serious?

[Rinksterk]

Nelson and Sunshin Lee if you include admirals.
Themistocles.
Stonewall Jackson.
Salah Al-din.

[jayrico]

Originally Posted by MMA Fighta

Jesus

LOL such an OT response.

[MMA Fighta]

Originally Posted by pobo

1. Julius Ceasar

3. Robert E Lee...He could of created more strategic positioning for the Confederates.

..For someone who had to work with constant shortages of supplies and dwindling number of men and somehow still manage to win a string of victories against the North's war machines is remarkable to the tee don't you think?

And if you're going praise Lee...Better mention Jackson too. Between the two, Jackson was the better tactical strategist, and the victory at Chancellorsville would've been impossible without him.

[MMA Fighta]

Originally Posted by jayrico

LOL such an OT response.

OT representin

[TheBigS]

Where would Sam Houston fit in on your list? Not saying he would be top ten, but he brilliantly organized the Texans into a coherent Army and carefully chose his battles with Santa Ana's army, beating what was on paper a superior army.

[Triangle_Man]

You guys only mentioned 'brilliant' generals with a legacy. If we're going on brilliance alone:

-Sir John Bradford
-General Scott. N. Charleston
-Adolphus the Giant
-Jean Theureaux Lukemeyer

[pobo]

Originally Posted by MMA Fighta

..For someone who had to work with constant shortages of supplies and dwindling number of men and somehow still manage to win a string of victories against the North's war machines is remarkable to the tee don't you think?

And if you're going praise Lee...Better mention Jackson too. Between the two, Jackson was the better tactical strategist, and the victory at Chancellorsville would've been impossible without him.

point taken, thanks.