[Cerberus87]

With the coming of The Dark Knight, this thread is imminent...who's hotter Maggie Gyllenhaal or Katie Holmes?

[dugforeva]

katie holmes is hotter, but maggie is a far far better actress.

[X The Dude X]

I'm going to have to go with Katie being hotter out of the two.

But Maggie is a much better actress, and she doesn't do that annoying shit of talking out the side of her mouth like Katie does.

So Katie wins in the looks dept, but Maggie wins in the other categories IMO.

[Neu!]

katie of course

[akutz1]

Maggie pwns katie holmes via Tom Cruise marriage

[2short]

Katie Holmes >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> MG

[viel cazzo]

Katie for scientology beliefs.

[Theprospect26]

I can't stand the way Katie looks....those droopy ass puppy eyes and that talking out of the side of her mouth all the time.

I'll take Maggie with the looks and talent any day of the week.

[RollinDownRodeo]

Honestly ever since Katie hooked up with Tom Cruise I don't find her attractive at all anymore and I used to think she was pretty hot. That totally ruined it for me. She needs to grow her hair longer again too.

[J Storm]

if i had to pick one to hit it and quit it, katie. anything longer than that, Maggie for sure. i'd beat up on her brother at family gatherings.