[Farkas Baxter]

Melvin????? get fuckin real. I laugh at anyone who knocks Anderson's striking, but uses Melvin's for trying to prove their case. Anderson Silva would tool Melvin any where.

[sha04]

there is no answer to the striking of Mr Silva just survival.

[aries]

Don't know why so many people are using Remy as an example of how Melvin would do against Silva! Remy's hands are poor, he has no power so much of that height and reach advantage doesn't exist. Anderson would be an entirely different prospect and I think he'd tool a wild brawler like Melvin with his long powerful straights and pin point accuracy. An easy victory for Anderson in MMA and a tough one in K1 but he takes both.

[Mochan]

Originally Posted by aries

Don't know why so many people are using Remy as an example of how Melvin would do against Silva! Remy's hands are poor, he has no power so much of that height and reach advantage doesn't exist. Anderson would be an entirely different prospect and I think he'd tool a wild brawler like Melvin with his long powerful straights and pin point accuracy. An easy victory for Anderson in MMA and a tough one in K1 but he takes both.

OMG this is why I'm embarassed to be called an Anderson Silva fan these days, these fanatic zealots are so bad they actually think Anderson Silva is better than Remy Bonjasky at striking.

[DSHO]

I still think Anderson would pick him apart! Anderson's chin is great and Melvin's gas tank is definatley suspect!

[Never_Back_Down]

Originally Posted by aries

Don't know why so many people are using Remy as an example of how Melvin would do against Silva! Remy's hands are poor, he has no power so much of that height and reach advantage doesn't exist. Anderson would be an entirely different prospect and I think he'd tool a wild brawler like Melvin with his long powerful straights and pin point accuracy. An easy victory for Anderson in MMA and a tough one in K1 but he takes both.

Maybe because hes 6'4 and weighs more than Silva

Also his hands used to set up his kicks, and they are also better, just doesnt use them as offense

[MMAmouse]

Originally Posted by Mochan

OMG this is why I'm embarassed to be called an Anderson Silva fan these days, these fanatic zealots are so bad they actually think Anderson Silva is better than Remy Bonjasky at striking.

Those are the same guys that were saying Liddell could be top 5 in K-1 before he lost to Rampage. Don't worry, once Anderson loses he will no longer be revered and whoever beat him will be the greatest thing since sliced bread.

[Day Man]

I think Anderson can hang with him on the feet, but the big difference is the ground game. I don't think Melvin has one, while Anderson is pretty fucking solid. Anderson probably takes this by sub

[MJS!]

He is definitely fun to watch but I'm not sure if he has the tools to finish someone like Anderson. He has a tendency to gas ,but his striking is dangerous. I would like to see how well he does against top notch ground guys.

[slammerfist]

u guys are delirious! no doubt anderson could fight K1