Wand>Rampage? Chuck>Wand? Rampage>Chuck? - Page 3

MIGUELOCO · 05-14-2008, 12:27 AM

anyways circle slash MMAth!!!

TheHegemon1 · 05-14-2008, 12:30 AM

Quote:

one of them has to be better than the other two

I really disagree that there has to be a "best" fighter. And most likely there never will be. Atleast in that weight class

TheHegemon1 · 05-14-2008, 12:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chucks_Nutz

Chuck rules over both of them. He crushed Silva and the two losses to Rampage were a fluke. The first time his corner through in the towel too soon. He was about to make a comeback and in the second fight it was a early stoppage. Chuck is going to hit Rampage so hard he is going to knock the black off of him. Mark my words, He will be LHW champion again and then he will move up to HW and KTFO Nogueira.

lol well played, Nutz

Stand&Strike714 · 05-14-2008, 12:37 AM

Only time will tell my friend

Majin Buu · 05-14-2008, 12:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JKS

Ummm, no he beat Arona in a championship fight. And thats 3x over Sak and 2 over Rampage. Wand has beat Henderson, Nakamura, and Mezger which are all solid fighters. He has more good wins then Rampage, not by much though.

Ok, so you count Nak, and Mezger for Wand. But you dont count Busta, Igor, or Illoukine for Rampage? Kinda biased there.

Igor was in his prime and a HW.

Busta is a credible win if Nak and Mezger are.

Illhoukine has wins over Couture and Justin mccully at the time. So he was credible.

Also Rampage went into K-1 and beat a world class K-1 fighter with his own rules. That is a huge accomplishment.

I still have Chuck as the best LHW ever. But Wand and Rampage are close.

MegaMegaRoboCop · 05-14-2008, 12:40 AM

Welcome to MMA math.

Here's a good string....

Wand > Henderson > Chonan > Anderson Silva > Henderson > Wand

Take that!

JKS · 05-14-2008, 12:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Majin Buu

Ok, so you count Nak, and Mezger for Wand. But you dont count Busta, Igor, or Illoukine for Rampage? Kinda biased there.

Igor was in his prime and a HW.

Busta is a credible win if Nak and Mezger are.

Illhoukine has wins over Couture and Justin mccully at the time. So he was credible.

Also Rampage went into K-1 and beat a world class K-1 fighter with his own rules. That is a huge accomplishment.

I still have Chuck as the best LHW ever. But Wand and Rampage are close.

Well I did say Wand but not by much. I'd still consider Mezger and Nak better wins then Igor and Busta. Both guys that Wand beat were consistent 205'ers. Eventhough, Igor was in his prime, I highely consider Igor overated, I mean common the guy lost to every good fighter he fought. I loved him as a fighter, his early fights, but he was never a solid consistent fighter at either weight.