[Kaydoh]

if that ended the p4p debate once and for all why is my post on page two of this thread?

[Explict Theory]

Originally Posted by Newman

Please note where this interview took place:

So where was his excuse when he got outboxed before the eyepoke?

[mr.allday]

Oh STFU! Bj Penn is an amazing fighter and talent wise he is probably the best. However he is not the P4P best. The Spider and Fedor are easily more proven commoditys.

[LynchRippin]

maybe.

[wisdom blows]

Originally Posted by keam02

The truth. Why? Just because you've fought in a bunch of weight classes doesn't make you the best. You have to actually win fights often and be dominant to be the p4p 1. Beating Sherk will help.


...but also, who the fuck cares? Everyone in the heavies is so concerned with stupid, useless lists and get all riled up when someone doesn't agree. They don't matter, and the p4p list matters even less.

actually, yes. the very definition of p4p is being great regardless of your weight class. and he has proved that by capturing titles at higher weight classes, and beating fighters that outway him by more than 30 lbs.

[BigCharlie_GNP]

Hard to argue, but a great case can be make for about 4 different guys.

.

[FREE BEER!]

I hope Sherk holds him down and farts in his face with his mouth open for 5 rounds.

Muscle Shark by UD.

[PainMerchant]

Fedor constantly fights guys who outweigh him by 200 pounds and are 10 feet tall and made out of iron so he should be #1 p4p........

[swirldog]

Thank God the p4p argument has been settled once and for all. Now what will I do with all my time?

[phil the void]

Originally Posted by wisdom blows

actually, yes. the very definition of p4p is being great regardless of your weight class. and he has proved that by capturing titles at higher weight classes, and beating fighters that outway him by more than 30 lbs.

If you're going by "beating guys that outweigh him by x amount of lbs.", than Fedor is undisputed.