Sherdog's New P4P Rankings

[BruceLeeOwnTito**]

Originally Posted by trollkin

Fedor is No1 P4P without any doubt. He is unbeaten. Anyone who does not agree is an idiot and moron. sorry i do not normally say things like that but come on guys.

I dont agree. He's not undefeated. He lost. Accept it. I think Fedor and Anderson are neck and neck. If he demolishes Arlovski then give it to Fedor. But then again if Andy knocks chuck into retirement...hehehe...

[JackThePimper]

Originally Posted by lunacyfrog

You are living in the past there, comparing career accomplishments.

Career-wise Fedor has the edge.

yeah silva is the man, he moves up to beat the best fighter in the world, patrick cote

boy, if you talk about top10 fights of these guys, you have to go in the past, with your logic, muhammad ali beat only old or dead boxers... damn are americans really stupid? or its only bush

[rymplej]

Originally Posted by JackThePimper

all time losses

Fedor: 0 (1) by an illegal elbow tko after seconds in the first round

A. Silva: 4

so you don't count Fedor's loss but you count Silva's illegal kick? That isn't biased at all . .

[Immelianenkoh]

Originally Posted by RobbieH

Everyone thinks fedor should be ahead of silva, but do you really want to give a guys whos fought ONCE this year the best p4p fighter in the world.

i agree he probably is. but he needs to fight more to prove it

Fedor is the best fighter in the world, and he has proven it.

[Immelianenkoh]

Originally Posted by rymplej

so you don't count Fedor's loss but you count Silva's illegal kick? That isn't biased at all . .

Silva committed a penalty worthy of disqualification...Fedor didn't. Fedor got cut by an illegal elbow.

Silva was at fault for his loss, Fedor was sliced open illegally in a fight he would have VERY easily dominated.

[rymplej]

Originally Posted by JackThePimper

yeah silva is the man, he moves up to beat the best fighter in the world, patrick cote

boy, if you talk about top10 fights of these guys, you have to go in the past, with your logic, muhammad ali beat only old or dead boxers... damn are americans really stupid? or its only bush

So is Ali still the best P4P boxer today?

[lunacyfrog]

Originally Posted by JackThePimper

yeah silva is the man, he moves up to beat the best fighter in the world, patrick cote

boy, if you talk about top10 fights of these guys, you have to go in the past, with your logic, muhammad ali beat only old or dead boxers... damn are americans really stupid? or its only bush

What the hell are you talking about?

[Hashmonkey]

Originally Posted by wilKO

Im just sayin that because Fedor fights at HW doesnt mean he should get extra credit. Its weak compared to 205. Randy found success at HW after being KOd twice at LHW. Brandon Vera has done nothing at LHW and was good at HW. At least Anderson is movin about looking for challenges.

Randy lost twice consecutively in hw before dropping weight and bitch slapping chuck and tito.
+
Vera kinda looked like shit at hw, pretty much the reason i'm guessing? he dropped to lhw in the first place.

[lunacyfrog]

Originally Posted by Immelianenkoh

Fedor is the best fighter in the world, and he has proven it.

He proved it during 2003-2005.

Since then, not so much.

Hope he gets back in action against some top comp.

Meanwhile, Silva is current number 1 for sure.

[JackThePimper]

Originally Posted by rymplej

so you don't count Fedor's loss but you count Silva's illegal kick? That isn't biased at all . .

kohsakas illegal ellbow = kohsakas blame

a. silvas illegal kick = silvas blame

result =

silvas loss was right

fedors loss was not right

deal with it, or tap out like silva