Sherdog's New P4P Rankings

[johnko]

Forrest should be at #1. I've beenn saying that the whole time!

Rampage was #1 p4p when Forrest finished him with the decision.

[lunacyfrog]

Originally Posted by Jack V. Savage

Well, beating Sylvia didn't help him so I can't imagine that beating AA would. The only thing Fedor can do to get to No. 1 is sign with the UFC. Then he can feast on inferior competition all he wants, and no one will mind.

Not true at all.

His impressive win over the albeit slumping Tim is the only thing keeping him at number 2!

[DocBlack]

Originally Posted by loke76

Silva
Always fights the smaller guys

GSP
Always fights the smaller guys

Fedor
Kicks ass from Feather weight to super super heavy...

HMC would smash GSP and Silva.. Yes i said it.. Fedor P4P no 1 by a mile. And were they all to fight each other, i think because of styles, GSP might have a better shot at beating Fedor than Silva, but both loose brutally

Do you know what "pound for pound" even means? You are sounding like a complete Shertard. Of course Fedor would murder all of those guys, but that wouldn't be pound for pound stupid.

[lunacyfrog]

Originally Posted by loke76

Silva
Always fights the smaller guys

GSP
Always fights the smaller guys

Fedor
Kicks ass from Feather weight to super super heavy...

HMC would smash GSP and Silva.. Yes i said it.. Fedor P4P no 1 by a mile. And were they all to fight each other, i think because of styles, GSP might have a better shot at beating Fedor than Silva, but both loose brutally

At 200-205 Silva is average for a MW. He is tiny compared to most LHWs and is moving up to fight them also.

GSP at 185 fight time is average for a WW.

Fedor has fought big guys, yes, but also little guys.

All three are excellent.

Currently, I rank them as

Silva
Fedor
GSP

[StPierreCanada]

Originally Posted by nuthead11

1. fedor
2. A. Silva
3. GSP
4. BJ Penn
5. Alveraz
6. torres
7. nogueira
8. faber
9. griffin
10. aoki

just puttin in my two cents :]

Yuck, thats one ugly P4P list IMO.

[Vespertilio]

Originally Posted by Jack V. Savage

Well, beating Sylvia didn't help him so I can't imagine that beating AA would. The only thing Fedor can do to get to No. 1 is sign with the UFC. Then he can feast on inferior competition all he wants, and no one will mind.

LOL! Brilliant!

[RobbieH]

Originally Posted by SlayerNPG

Fedor is #1 until he loses. LOL @ GSP being ahead of Fedor. Get back to me when Fedor get's tooled by someone on the Matt Serra level.

well thats going to be a while when the guy fights once a year

[gsp-413]

I stick with mine.

1. GSP
1. Fedor
1. Anderson Silva
4. Penn
5. Forrest
6. NOG
7. Rampage
8. Franklin
9. Machida
10. Couture
11. Shogun (low due to inactivity)
12. Henderson
13. Rashad
14. Florian
15. Fitch
16. Arlovski
17. Lesnar
18. Alves
19. Barnett
20 Nick Diaz (Yeah, I said it)

I'll Throw Torres in there somewhere.

[Azn_Assassin]

You went to a thread made a month ago to post that?

[gsp-413]

Rampage made it because he deserves too. Rampage is a monster and deff. deserves top 10 TS. You're an idiot.