Sherdog's New P4P Rankings

[Vespertilio]

I seriously don't see what top comp you people are talking about that Silva has destroyed. Henderson isn't half the fighter at MW he's at LHW. He preformes much better when he gets dosen't have to that much. I remember alot of decisions some of them being very quenstionable back in PRIDE for Hendo.

Last I saw of Anderson was a pretty ok preformance against Cote. Sure he was winning but he should beat the shit out of a guy like that. And as far as 205 goes I'm not sure Irvin is even a top 15 fighter. I believe Silva would beat Griffin fairly easy if he got the chance but there's still alot of speculation to be made about Silva. Fedor has proved himself pretty much from the start and last time I saw him he was as solid as ever.

[Gotti McCarran]

Originally Posted by Sinnaman Toast

Why? Silva has shown that he can hang in two different weight classes, with absolute brutal dominance. Also he has fought a lot more top competition than Fedor for quite sometime. I mean lets get real, the closest thing to a top 10 heavyweight Fedor fought was Big Tim, and c'mon it's Timmey.

Hahahaahahhaa. God damn that was a retarded comment. Far as I'm concerned Silva has 3 fights. Dan and both the Franklin bouts.

[R.Tseng]

C'mon,leaving out Norifumi in any p4p ranking just ain't right.

[Kswin09]

Originally Posted by UFC's Pride

For me it's either
1. Fedor
2. GSP
3. Silva

or

1. GSP
2. Fedor
3. Silva

I like silva but i jus don't think he's done more then the other 2...

Are you kidding me. Silva's last nine fights have not gone to a decision. The guy has not lost the title since 2006. GSP just back the title in 2008. Silva has lost ot some bums but he not lost in the UFC. He has not lost in eight fights. He went up to LHW and smashed a guy who is legit for a warm-up fight in LHW divison.

I don't see how GSP is ranked over Fedor either.

Fedor has not lost since 2000. He was the Pride Heavyweight champion for 3 years.

GSP is good but common. GSP won the belt and lost it to Matt Serra.

[lunacyfrog]

Originally Posted by Gottlander

You're not making any sense: Silva was a Pride fighter who destroyed the UFC 185 division.

Not sure what you are getting at. Silva has fought in many organizations. I believe he has more fights in the UFC than anywhere else.

[BODY_ARTS_GUY]

Yeah as usual sherdog jacked em up' - ahhh why does Faber dropped whereas Jackson has such a high ranking??? If Sherdog had half a brain they would just make the list the top 5 - because it really doesn't make any sense arguing over 5-10

[dickerdown]

Originally Posted by CRAWFISH

I'm not one much for P4P rankings, but this new one is pretty bad. What about fighters like Kid Yamamoto, Faber, Mousasi and Eddie Alvarez. How did Rampage make the list?

its not the best list but considering faber just got TKO'd in the first round, I'm not surprised that hes not on there, nor do i think he deserves to be anymore. i dont think rampage should be on the list either

[lunacyfrog]

Originally Posted by Vespertilio

Sherdog is just making another sad attempt to suck on the UFC's balls after the bad blood with them and Dana. No way in hell do they pick Silva over Fedor. I've listened to every dam after the bell and round table show and I always heard Fedor was the p4p #1 according to them.

I don't care much for the list but after Sivlas questionable preformance against Cote and just the fact that Fedor is a way smaller guy for his divission plus the biggest fact of them all that silva has losses on his record is more than enough.

Fedor never had a mediocre preformance. he never even lost a round. If you're gonna argue against me about his so called loss go watch that fight, see how BS that was for yourself.

He did lose to Arona. He just got the decision.

But anyway, these are current rankings right?

Based on current results?

Cause if so, Silva is #1.

[Jack V. Savage]

Originally Posted by lunacyfrog

Not sure what you are getting at. Silva has fought in many organizations. I believe he has more fights in the UFC than anywhere else.

Not sure if you were on Sherdog when he came to the UFC, but Pride fans predicted that he would run through the division, and ignorant UFC fans cried that he was overrated and would lose to or struggle with Leben.

[Jack V. Savage]

Originally Posted by BODY_ARTS_GUY

Yeah as usual sherdog jacked em up' - ahhh why does Faber dropped whereas Jackson has such a high ranking??? If Sherdog had half a brain they would just make the list the top 5 - because it really doesn't make any sense arguing over 5-10

Here's the correct top five:

1. Fedor


2. Penn
3. Kid
4. Silva
5. Torres