Official Sherdog P4P Discussion (threads merged)

[robbyp]

Originally Posted by Truth25

GSP is hands down the best pound for pound fighter in the world. Fedor hasnt done jack lately and hes scared to step up the competition, he would rather fights washed up ufc guys and pad the record. Gsp has recent wins over top competition and has redeemed both losses in his career. Also, he is far more well rounded than any other fighter. The pound for pound rankings are as follows. 1. GSP(especially if he beats alves) 2. Anderson( fights better comp than fedor lately) 3. Fedor

lol, look at all the newbie MMA fan retards that have come to Sherdog. Anybody that has been following MMA since Fedor began his run of dominance knows that he's the #1 fighter in the world.

[phishin42]

Originally Posted by robbyp

lol, look at all the newbie MMA fan retards that have come to Sherdog. Anybody that has been following MMA since Fedor began his run of dominance knows that he's the #1 fighter in the world.

I've been following MMA since long before Fedor and his run in PRIDE. He's not the #1 P4P and never has been. He's been rocked in several of his fights, and most of his victories have been over straight cans. He beat Nogs, Sylvia, Arlovski. After that, who? Josh Barnett, the most boring fighter ever who's lost to LHW's in the UFC?

There are many fighters who have far more impressive resumes. During his time in PRIDE, Silva had a far better P4P resume, as did Dan Henderson, who also beat Nogs THE SAME WAY FEDOR DID (decision), while weighing a good 50 lbs less than him.

[King of KO's]

Fedor #1 hands down.

[Spawned_Fighter]

good fights. went 3-0 for my picks for the big three

but i guess anyone would be if they were this easy to call


back on topic:
1 fedor
2 gsp
3 anderson

[wilKO]

GSP has beaten better competition than Fedor and would beat Fedor if they were the same size IMO.

[Belfegor]

POUND BY POUND ranking after UFC 100

01) Fedor Emelianenko (30-1, 1 NC)
02) Lyoto Machida (15-0)
03) Anderson Silva (24-4)
04) Miguel Torres (37-1)
05) Mike Thomas Brown (22-4)
06) Jake Shields (23-4-1)
07) Georges St. Pierre (19-2)
08) B.J. Penn (13-5-1)
09) Demian Maia (10-0)
10) Gray Maynard (7-0, 1 NC)

Georges St. Pierre is a very bad striker and very predictable fighter for this isn' t in the top 5. Thiago Alves is only a one dimensional fighter (striker). BJ Penn is better fighter that GSP, the only reason because BJ lose against GSP is your cardio.

Michael Bisping Rest in Peace (Ultimate Fighter Finale 3 - UFC 100)

Fedor destroys easily GSP, by KO, TKO or submission.

[KebAMP]

Originally Posted by Belfegor

POUND BY POUND ranking after UFC 100

01) Fedor Emelianenko (30-1, 1 NC)
02) Lyoto Machida (15-0)
03) Anderson Silva (24-4)
04) Miguel Torres (37-1)
05) Mike Thomas Brown (22-4)
06) Jake Shields (23-4-1)
07) Georges St. Pierre (19-2)
08) B.J. Penn (13-5-1)
09) Demian Maia (10-0)
10) Gray Maynard (7-0, 1 NC)

Georges St. Pierre is a very bad striker and very predictable fighter for this isn' t in the top 5. Thiago Alves is only a one dimensional fighter (striker). BJ Penn is better fighter that GSP, the only reason because BJ lose against GSP is your cardio.

Michael Bisping Rest in Peace (Ultimate Fighter Finale 3 - UFC 100)

Fedor destroys easily GSP, by KO, TKO or submission.

This is ridiculous. Never seen a top 10 P4P list so biased, ever

[dvd_collector]

if fedor beats lesnar he seals P4P throne! the P4P ranking changes every now and then like manny pacquiao and gayweather in boxing. GSP overtook silva in my ranking.

for the oldies who has been following MMA since their birth it does'nt make you god that you laugh at newbies opinions. this is a free thread and making you watch MMA first does'nt always make your opinion correct! and yeah it does'nt mean that because you have more posts make you correct either...post paders!

i've seen fedors career too and i think he's currently the best but the thing is other fighters are catching-up. better get to the UFC fedor or the only one who can beat lesnar is triple H!

and geez who knows lesnar may even be P4P someday which i hate to see.

[doyawanna]

Originally Posted by Belfegor

POUND BY POUND ranking after UFC 100

01) Fedor Emelianenko (30-1, 1 NC)
02) Lyoto Machida (15-0)
03) Anderson Silva (24-4)
04) Miguel Torres (37-1)
05) Mike Thomas Brown (22-4)
06) Jake Shields (23-4-1)
07) Georges St. Pierre (19-2)
08) B.J. Penn (13-5-1)
09) Demian Maia (10-0)
10) Gray Maynard (7-0, 1 NC)

Georges St. Pierre is a very bad striker and very predictable fighter for this isn' t in the top 5. Thiago Alves is only a one dimensional fighter (striker). BJ Penn is better fighter that GSP, the only reason because BJ lose against GSP is your cardio.

Michael Bisping Rest in Peace (Ultimate Fighter Finale 3 - UFC 100)

Fedor destroys easily GSP, by KO, TKO or submission.

I can only hope this list is a joke. Wow, just wow.

[zec1234]

Let's see how P4P picture was changing in last 2 years.
Here are careers of 8 fighters that are usualy present in this kind of discussion.



Y Axis is Current Score (nobody has ever reached 800 points).
X Axis is a Cut Off Date (yyyy-mm).
Current Score Points are based on the scoring on
Current Rankings Top 25 - Pound-for-Pound