Official Sherdog P4P Discussion (threads merged)

[kingpaolo]

GSP hands down

[JackThePimper]

Originally Posted by kingpaolo

GSP hands down

GSP: Fedor is the best pound for pound fighter

[xxxwarez]

Originally Posted by JackThePimper

GSP: Fedor is the best pound for pound fighter

he wud never say "im the best p4p". im not saying he is tho. but he certainly is top 3.

[Sax MMA]

agree

[Arkray Wilbuck]

Any P4P discussion has to include Fedor/GSP/Anderson/Machida/Torres

[IRONFIST]

Im going to have to say at there peak. Royce Gracie. P4P must include a fighter like Royce who could win fights against people double his weight. If you can own in a open weight competition only weighing 160 pounds you are a beast. Just thought i would throw that in there. Also if you can leave your weight class and beat good comp you should also be noted. Thats why i would say Anderson Silva and GSP should be in the top over Fedor also. Tho GSP has not done it yet i believe he could win fights in a higher weight class. Miguel Torres comes to mind also along with BJ Penn. 1.Royce Gracie 2. Anderson Silva 3. Georges St.Pierre 4. Fedor 5. BJ Penn Also note: Miguel Torres- Kazushi Sakuraba- Dan Henderson- Lyoto Machida- Mike Brown- Takanori Gomi.

[JackThePimper]

Originally Posted by IRONFIST

Also if you can leave your weight class and beat good comp you should also be noted. Thats why i would say Anderson Silva and GSP should be in the top over Fedor also.

[IRONFIST]

Your a douchebag. You must be Fedor nuthugger and your mad that P4P GSP and Anderson are above him. There is nothing wrong with swinging from Fedor's grundle man dont take it out on me. And after reading all your post you just argue with people and ride Fedor's nuts. I cant wait till Fedor comes to the UFC and Brock Lesnar owns him and all you Fedor nuthuggers hop on Brocks sack. You have 1,400 posts out of all of em 5 are knowledgeable.

[JackThePimper]

Originally Posted by IRONFIST

Your a douchebag. You must be Fedor nuthugger and your mad that P4P GSP and Anderson are above him. There is nothing wrong with swinging from Fedor's grundle man dont take it out on me. And after reading all your post you just argue with people and ride Fedor's nuts.

you read all my posts? do you need a job?

but yes, you are right, fedor only fought heavier guys like a prime hunt, schilt, prime fujita, sylvia, hmc, ogawa, schall, and others. fedor is a small hw and silva a big mw btw.,but that is nothing against anderson silva's list of "heavier" (he never fought really heavier guys, the self with GSP) opponents: holy freakin shit, it is only one, but hell, damn, fuck, JAMES IRVIN! you opened my eyes.

[IRONFIST]

I didnt say hes not up there. He is in the top 5 of every P4P thread vote or poll ever made. Your the one that got mad at my opinion. Im not god with the almighty list i just put my opinion up and you got all pissy pants because where Fedor was on my list. I think eventually with in the next 2 years Brock Lesnar will be high on that list also. I dont like Brock Lesnar much but i think he will beat Mir and i think he could beat Fedor when the time came/if it does. Then everyone will be on Brocks nuts. Mind you i dont like Brock Lesnar. But it can happen easily.