[Sparks728]

War Mayhem

[alexismachine]

Originally Posted by Mackavelli

Nog is definitely no2 of all time, hes done a lot more than randy. Randy beat gonzaga and couture, nog beat the guy who beat gonzaga and finished big tim.

Randy beat gonzaga and couture? He beat himself?

[Strict Ten]

i have to agree, Randy is my favorite fighter but Nog is number 2 by far

[tommy508]

i feel couture is disrespecting noguiera by not fighting him. by the way thats a dream fight i would be just as excited to see that as fedor v.s couture

[IIIIIIII]

Originally Posted by krelianx

I think you just looked at my statement and didn't read my argument.

Your argument isn't going to negate the fact that Randy Couture has a 16-8 record. Can your argument refute that?

[mycorona135]

Originally Posted by Kimjo

"not so sure"

Randy dont deserve to be ranked world wide as a hw before he have had more fights. He had a lucky swing vs Big Tim, sure. But 9 out of 10 times Tim would beat randy. And Gonzaga is the most overrated fighter of all times. Put him against Kimbo and he will lose.

Had Randy fought vs and won against AA and Werdum he would easly been top 5, maybe top 3 but this will never happen.

i agree randy shouldnt be ranked but i disagree that tim wins that fight 9/10 times... randy did win by ud..

[Joe_Armstrong]

Only thing is he takes a lot of punishment before submitting someone. He should change that and keep on to the belt for a while, except for if Mir takes it

[Montaro]

Originally Posted by krelianx

Randy is, I think, the greatest fighter in MMA history at this point. What he did when he came back and regained the HW title against Sylvia was historical, to say the least. But again, it is ridiculous how much people overlook its only been two victories in the HW division that has put him on the upper echelon. Nog has been beating top competition for years, consistently. I'm not sure Couture deserves this high praise, insofar as HW rankings is concerned.

Randy could of cemeted himself as one of the GOAT's IF he stayed and defeated Nog.

[Darkeonz]

Originally Posted by Hinch

Every career has its controversial decision. Just like Fedor x Arona. Or Hendo x a fuckload of people according to Sherdog.

He somewhat vindicated it by beating Sylvia. Something Ricco failed to do in his prime.

i agree to an extend. However the nog vs ricco fight was basically ricco beating nog the entire time. it was an obvious win for ricco... even the commentators were speechless.

Fedor vs arona wasn't controversial. Arona was laying ontop of fedor whenever he got fedor down.. that's all he did. It went to a third round which fedor dominated.

[#1 HW Fedor]

Originally Posted by Temar241

wow yea id have to agree with you and im a ufc fan for the most part.... nog is ridiculously legit. I would totally put him ahead of couture on the all time list.

i wonder if he would beat couture right now or not... I duno why that fight never had a chance of happening, or why couture had no desire to fight such a great fighter.

Sick joke?

Randy and legit never go together in the same sentence boy...