Quote:
Originally Posted by inetwarrior
Sam Greco, Vernom White, Sam Hoger, David Heath are not even in the top30 LHW rankings
|
Well thats your opinion, but weather they're top fighters now or not is irrelevant. Sam Greco is a good kickboxer who outside of the Machida fight is undefeated in MMA and weighs 50 pounds more than Machida. Vernon White is always a dangerous fight for anyone losing record or not, Sam Hoger was in shape then and a good fighter, David Heath was undefeated and a very good fighter.
Quote:
|
Kaz and soko even though i like them are far from great and so is Stephan Bonnar. Barely top15
|
Soko was easily top 15 at the time, some say top 10 and some could even argue that he was top 5. Same with Nakamura but to a much lesser extent. Bonnar has only been stopped once and that was by Machida himself while his only other losses are to the current and former champion.
Quote:
|
Than you have the Rich Franklin fight wich was more than 5 years ago. While we are at it Rich isnt a the top10 LHW yet.
|
But he was a veteran of 13+ fights at the time and undefeated, while it was Machidas 3rd career fight. Thats a pretty impressive win.
Quote:
|
Bj Penn well he is a top 155!! pound fighter not a LHW and even against him he couldnt win by domination or finish him..
|
Kinda says alot about Penn though doesn't it? That one of the worlds top Lightheavyweights couldn't dominate him. I mean seriously if Machida couldn't who could?
Quote:
|
Tito Ortiz hmm not top10 and who cares if he arguably beat evans wich he did imo, because i think rashad is overrated.
|
Right, so because YOU think Rashad is overrated beating Rashad isn't worthy of a top 10 place?
Of course you still haven't explained how Wanderlei was top 5 and Tito isn't. Is that because you don't think Kieth Jardine is overrated?
Quote:
|
Machida has to beat a top5 fighter than he deserves it. Rampage does deserve it more though as for now IMO.
|
When was the last time Rampage beat one of your top 5 fighters? I'll give you Dan Henderson but which top 5 fighter did he beat to get that title? Marvin Eastman is anything but top 5.
Quote:
|
I dont hate on machida because i know he is very skilled and top3 LHW but he hasnt beat anyone in the recent to deserve a titlteshot over rampage.
|
You could argue that Tito is a bigger win than Wanderlei because Tito actually has a win over Wanderlei but whatever.
Quote:
Bonnar: good fighter but more like a gate keeper
Franklin: Beat him in 2003
Penn: beating a LW does make you LHW #1 contender
Greco: whatever
White: 6 fights under .500
Hoger: losing record in the UFC
Heath: losing record in the UFC
Nakamura: losing record in the UFC
Sokodju: losing record in the UFC
Ortiz: top 10 LHW at the time
|
Bonnar: Only time he's been finished, only other losses were to the champion and former champion.
Franklin: KO'd him before it was cool.
Penn: More of a test to how talented Penn is.
Greco: Much bigger fighter, more experience in the ring and only MMA loss to Machida.
White: Very underrated and dangerous fighter, proof that records mean very little in MMA.
Hoger: Still a good fighter.
Heath: Was undefeated in the UFC and MMA at the time.
Nakamura: 1st of two fights in the UFC.
Sokoudjou: 1st of three fights in the UFC.
Ortiz: Yes.