[Madmick]

Haha, now we see the infant that I debate. "Game Revolution" gave SWKOTR a "B". "Just because you found 'one' website..."

You should really carefully read someone's argument before you write something that so brutally exposes your overriding bias and lack of comprehension. Gamerankings isn't one critical review. It's all of them. It's a combined score of every critical score out there. In fact, they even divide these compilation ratings into a "Main" score (the score of the composite of all the major reviewers) and a "Total" score (including less regular reviewers' scores this time). This means it has absorbed Game Revolution's votes as well.

Relying on the opinion of one game reviewer reveals your provincial comprehension of gaming.

Gamerankings is the site I quoted that showed 4x as many exclusive games scoring above 90% for the PS2 than the Xbox. Hardly a fanboy site, eh? That might have been the reason I gave all the categories to PS2 except shooter and RPG.

Now you're bashing Halo and Oblivion? YOU'RE a riot. YOU'RE the one who just lost all credibility.

PS2 had more consoles sold. Thus, it had more "hits." But you'll note at Gamerankings that their RPG's do not score as high with the users as the Xbox games. And Gamerankings has more than 1,000 votes for all of these games: eliminating any mathematical margin of error (because the standard deviation becomes nominal at 1,000...this is the reason political polls only poll this many people).

Child, please, this argument was lost two posts up. You're only making PS2 whores look more and more stupid with comments like, "xbox's only claim to fame, halo, elder scrolls, forza motor sports, and mech warrior. those are the only games worth owning for the xbox." You clearly don't know anything about the Xbox, and your personal preference, Shadow of the Colossus, is pretty much only held by you and two other people in the world to be better than SWKOTR.

As per you, explosives: if you enjoy a mouse and PC Gaming, then by all means, don't buy an Xbox. That's a valid point. Personally, I hate PC gaming. I like the consoles. I'll take PS2 or Xbox over the PC any day of the week.