View Single Post
Old 07-06-2009, 10:33 AM   #158 (permalink)
huhwah**
Banned
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: anaheim
Posts: 1,923
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ruprecht View Post
I just watched the fight and thought another parochial Aussie should chime in.
No doubt Carnage screwed up... if you look at his eyes it was target fixation.
He was so keen to jump on Spong and finish it, he was barely paying attention to the Ref.
...but given that the ref was so indecisive and backed out the way as he signalled, the fact that the fight was over, the fact that there was no malice involved, there is no way that it should have been a no contest.
Carnage was robbed.

Great fight though...
I watched the fight just now as well, and being a dutchman myself and a zealous adherent to our delusional belief that everything dutch is inherently great and superior, I still have to admit that I would feel more comfortable with a win for Carnage.

The referee didn't make it clear to both fighters that the fight had been stopped. One of the fighters continued to attack, but did no real damage to the other fighter. The referee gave the win to carnage by waving it off, the fact that he did not fully make this clear to carnage is 100% the referee's fault. It is not like carnage would not have won had the referee not made this mistake, because the fight was already over by the time carnage attacked spong after the 10 count. So there, judged by criteria of fairness the fight should go to carnage. The fight itself showed that either man can knock the other out, and this win does not mean one fighter is clearly better than the other. Congratulations Carnage, even though on paper this is declared a N.C.
huhwah** is offline   Reply With Quote