I went with Tiffin for my new place. I went with black in the "wrestling surface" and I couldn't be happier. The old place I trained at used Dollamur and there is no difference in quality and you'll save a ton of money. Also the shipping is really quick (depending on location of course) and the customer service is good too.
Tiffin Athletic Mats - Gymnastics Equipment, Cheerleading Floors, Martial Arts Flooring, Wrestling Mats, Physical Education, Fitness and Exercise Mat Manufacturer