Sherdog Mixed Martial Arts Forums - View Single Post

BigKO34 · 01-07-2009, 11:37 AM

It all really depends on what you think a P4P ranking should reperesent. Which is the problem with P4P rankings.

First, you have the people who go by record and record alone. If you like this style, then GSP is ahead of Penn in P4P.

Then there are the people who rank P4P as fighters who are great in their own division, but have shown that they can fight people outside of their weight class( or bigger people in Fedor's case) and win or do well. If you go by this, BJ is ahead of GSP.

Just depends on how you view P4P rankings.

01-07-2009, 11:37 AM	#22 (permalink)
BigKO34 Orange Belt Join Date: Mar 2005 Posts: 316	It all really depends on what you think a P4P ranking should reperesent. Which is the problem with P4P rankings. First, you have the people who go by record and record alone. If you like this style, then GSP is ahead of Penn in P4P. Then there are the people who rank P4P as fighters who are great in their own division, but have shown that they can fight people outside of their weight class( or bigger people in Fedor's case) and win or do well. If you go by this, BJ is ahead of GSP. Just depends on how you view P4P rankings. __________________ Violence is not the answer, but it gives you time to think of one.