View Single Post
Old 05-30-2008, 05:12 PM   #110 (permalink)
jamesmichael7

White Belt
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Charlotte, NC
Posts: 123
Quote:
Originally Posted by Titan416 View Post
It was thought up by a lawyer with absolutely no background in science and has been proven completely and utterly incorrect in a court of law.

America is a joke.
Philip Johnson (who I assume you're referring to) did not think up ID. Johnson critiqued Neo-Darwinian philosophy and argumentation.

If anyone is credited with "thinking up" modern ID, it would have to be cryptographers, forensics, SETI researchers, and archeologists. All guys like Dembski, Behe, Meyer and Woodward did was apply it to the realm of biology.

ID should not be taught in schools though, in my opinion, as anything other than theoretical or philosophical. It hasn't had time to establish itself as a scientific discipline in full form...yet. Heck, even 90% of ID proponents attach all kinds of baggage to what would otherwise be a completely uncontroversial claim--complex specified information is most likely the product of intelligent agency. Period.
__________________
JMS
Micah 7:7

Felice Herrig (my girl)
A.Silva (precise)
R.Franklin (role model)
Rampage (funny)
GSP (unreal)
Cung Le (timing)
Machida (genius)
Quarry (classy)
Renzo (genuine)
jamesmichael7 is offline   Reply With Quote